Try this: think of the word apple. You probably don't see the letters; you see an apple. Maybe red, maybe green, maybe you can almost smell it. Now think of justice. Much harder to find a picture for, isn't it?
The Canadian psychologist Allan Paivio built a theory on this in the 1970s, and worked it out in detail in a whole book in 1986. In his view, memory works on two channels: one for words, one for pictures. Whatever you have both for is much easier to remember and recall.
What is dual coding?
Dual coding means putting a picture next to the words: a diagram, a drawing, a timeline, a chart. Not as decoration, but so that the picture tells the same thing as the text, just in a different form.
Words and pictures reach memory along two separate routes. If you have both, you can bring the same thing back along either one.
If you've learned something in words and in a picture, you have two "hooks" for it. If the definition won't come in the test, the diagram might, and you can work your way back to the answer from there.
What does research say?
Concrete words are easier to remember. In Paivio's experiments, people remembered words that are easy to picture (elephant, bridge) far better than abstract words (opportunity, value). This is called the concreteness effect, and it's one of the main pieces of evidence for dual coding.
Words and pictures together beat words alone. Richard Mayer and colleagues spent decades studying how we learn from text and pictures. One of their most stable findings is the multimedia principle: when an explanation comes with a well-matched diagram, students understand the material better and solve problems based on it better. In Mayer and Anderson's 1991 experiment, for example, they explained how a pump works. Those who got the words and the animation together solved the problems far better than those who got words alone.
Drawing helps in itself. In 2016, Jeffrey Wammes and colleagues looked at what happens when you draw words instead of writing them. People remembered the words they had drawn much better, even when they had only a few seconds to draw and drew badly. It's not the beauty of the drawing that counts, but having to turn the word into a picture.
No, you're not a 'visual learner'
Many people have heard that there are visual, auditory and kinaesthetic learners, and that everyone learns best in their own style. Research doesn't back this up. According to Pashler and colleagues' 2008 review, there's no reliable evidence that teaching matched to a style gives better results. Dual coding is the opposite idea: everyone benefits from getting words and pictures, not just "visual learners".
Which pictures work?
Not every picture is a good one. For dual coding you need a picture that carries content:
- Timeline: historical events, the steps of a process.
- Flowchart: what follows from what, what causes what (like the water cycle).
- Chart: numbers, proportions, comparisons.
- Simple drawing: a cell, a circuit, a character from a novel.
- Table or visual summary: two things side by side.
Decorative pictures (a cute cartoon at the start of a chapter), on the other hand, don't help, and can even pull your attention away.
How to do it
- Read a section, and think: how could I draw this?
- Draw it simply, with stick figures, arrows and a few labels. It doesn't need to be pretty.
- Connect it to the text: write the keywords next to the drawing.
- Explain the drawing in your own words, as if you were showing it to someone.
- When you revise, redraw it from memory. That turns dual coding into recall too.
Example
Biology: blood circulation
The textbook describes the pulmonary and systemic circulation over two pages. You make a simple drawing: a four-chambered heart in the middle, the lungs at the top, the body at the bottom. Blue arrows go from the right side of the heart to the lungs, red arrows from the lungs back to the left side and from there to the body. Next to each arrow, a word: "low in oxygen", "rich in oxygen". Before the test you redraw it from memory on a blank page.
Try it: draw it!
Draw, simply, how rain gets back up into the clouds. It doesn't need to be pretty: stick figures, arrows and a few words are enough. Then look at the example.
Common mistakes
Decoration instead of content. Notes full of stickers and cartoon characters are cheerful, but they're not dual coding. A picture helps when it tells the same thing as the text.
Copying the picture. Redrawing the textbook's diagram exactly is better than nothing, but inventing your own diagram for a piece of text is worth far more. Translating words into a picture is what strengthens the memory.
Drawings that are too complex. It doesn't need to be art. If a drawing takes half an hour, most of that time goes on drawing, not learning. Stick figures, arrows and boxes are plenty.
A picture without words. Dual coding means words and pictures. Two weeks later you won't know what the arrows in an unlabelled diagram mean. Write the keywords next to it.
"I'm just not a drawing person." The effect of drawing doesn't depend on talent. In Wammes's experiment, bad drawings helped just as much.
Tip
If an idea is too abstract to draw, find an example or an analogy for it, and draw that. Inflation is hard to draw, but a basket that gets smaller and smaller for the same money is easy.
What it's good at
- Two ways to bring back the same thing.
- Diagrams show connections that text only describes.
- Drawing strengthens the memory in itself, even if you're bad at drawing.
- It helps everyone, not just 'visual learners'.
Where it falls short
- Hard to find a good picture for abstract ideas.
- Easy to spend more time on looks than on content.
- Decorative pictures without content don't help.
- On its own it doesn't replace recall and review.
Combine it with other techniques
Dual coding goes with almost every other technique. A mind map is a mix of words and pictures by design. The absurd images of the memory palace use the same effect. Feel free to draw diagrams on the right side of your Cornell notes. And redrawing a picture from memory is active recall too.
Mini test: what do you remember?
No scrolling back up. That's the whole point.
Sources
- Paivio, A. (1971). Imagery and verbal processes. Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
- Paivio, A. (1986). Mental representations: A dual coding approach. Oxford University Press.
- Mayer, R. E., & Anderson, R. B. (1991). Animations need narrations: An experimental test of a dual-coding hypothesis. Journal of Educational Psychology, 83(4), 484–490. doi:10.1037/0022-0663.83.4.484
- Mayer, R. E. (2009). Multimedia learning (2nd ed.). Cambridge University Press.
- Wammes, J. D., Meade, M. E., & Fernandes, M. A. (2016). The drawing effect: Evidence for reliable and robust memory benefits in free recall. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 69(9), 1752–1776. doi:10.1080/17470218.2015.1094494
- Pashler, H., McDaniel, M., Rohrer, D., & Bjork, R. (2008). Learning styles: Concepts and evidence. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 9(3), 105–119. doi:10.1111/j.1539-6053.2009.01038.x